Duder

Gigabyte X38-DQ6 vs Asus Maximus Formula

Recommended Posts

Το Χ38 είναι το πολυαναμενόμενο high end chipset της Intel το οποίο αναμένεται να κερδίσει τις καρδιές των απανταχού enthusiast. Ένα κύμα υλοποιήσεων αναμένεται να κατακλύσει την σύντομα αγορά και το δίλημμα που τίθεται είναι: Χ38 ναι, ποιάς εταιρίας όμως;

Εδώ θα δούμε τις υλοποιήσεις των δυο μεγαλύτερων κατασκευαστών μητρικών πλακετών: του Χ38-DQ6 της Gigabyte και του Maximus Formula της ASUS. Και τα δύο βασίζονται στο Χ38 αυτό όμως δε σημαίνει πως αποδίδουν/συμπεριφέρονται με τον ίδιο τρόπο...

74943646ao3.jpg

ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA

18309314fs1.jpg

Clear CMOS the easy way...

81201624qq5.jpg

8 Power Phase design...

21599166ty2.jpg

Υδρόψυξη για το NB...

73935212my5.jpg

67191671dq8.jpg

Dual Phase PWM for vDIMM...

29945345ku2.jpg

Στην Maximus Formula υπάρχουν LEDs για κεντρικά συστατικά της μητρικής (vcore, vdimm, vmch,) τα οποία ανάβουν όταν η τάση βρίσκεται εντός συγκεκριμένων ορίων...

CPU Vcore LED...

33217991gb6.jpg

Northbridge Voltage LED...

32217423td6.jpg

VDimm Voltage LED...

13087650yk1.jpg

Southbridge Voltage LED...

54625352ud7.jpg

Το BIOS της Maximus...

80583762un5.jpg

93567569tf5.jpg

27910663wm9.jpg

37821124et7.jpg

13009586ae4.jpg

83139667jm4.jpg

39607638vn2.jpg

Gigabyte X38-DQ6

66464923hl0.jpg

Quad Triple Phase power regulators...

44001494hr6.jpg

Heat pipe solutions for the Mosfets, Northbridge and Southbridge...

53130359sf5.jpg

Crazy cool heat fins...

76312512nx0.jpg

DQ6 BIOS shots...

86048653ea5.jpg

60551321ze8.jpg

22330139pu9.jpg

10284468nd3.jpg

40185107to1.jpg

16717825sh4.jpg

51500314bi0.jpg

50182794zx7.jpg

79391207fw8.jpg

10td5.jpg

Pre testing...

vrzonetechnologybeatsgijw5.jpg

Benchmarking - 3DMark 06, PC Mark 05, Company of Heroes, Win RAR and SuperPi 8M

PCMark 05:

23069090zq3.gif

3DMark 06:

84608838jl6.gif

WinRAR Benchmark Tool:

45346841we5.gif

SUPERPI 8M:

86939577eq0.gif

Company of Heroes:

94749775hj8.gif

Overclocking

In our overclocking test, we aim to find out the highest FSB achievable, using a duo core and a quad core CPU Chip, the Intel Core 2 Duo E6550 and the Core 2 Extreme QX6850.

Using the E6550 chip, we are able to push the FSB to 484Mhz on the ASUS Maximus Formula.

95056892qc5.jpg

Using the Core 2 Quad Extreme QX6850, we are able to achieve a fsb of 460Mhz on the Maximus Formula.

90924883zy9.jpg

Now heading over to the Gigabyte board, we use the Easy Tune setup and bump the fsb up to 480Mhz with the E6550 on the DQ6.

95596087qt9.jpg

Now using the Core 2 Quad Extreme QX6850, we push the fsb to 475Mhz using the DQ6.

58942265xc2.jpg

Conclusion - The Maximus or the X-38 DQ6???

The Gigabyte actually commands a higher stock FSB compared to the Maximus! However, we are unsure whether the issue is with the board as we do not have other X38 boards to compare these 2 boards against at the moment. Overclocking headroom on the Gigabyte board looks promising though, with such an extensive variety of voltage options which you probably may not use and higher grade electronic components used to ensure a leading edge, with proper cooling we believe this board would have potential to scale to greater heights.

On the performance side, enthusiast may take the liking to the Maximus, judging from the benchmark results. Although we received just the board alone, albeit the initial release of the bios, we believe that newer revisions would eventually help in churning our higher performance figures from the maximus. Overclocking however could be improved although the newer BIOSes are still undisclosed. What makes the maximus standout? ASUS Republic of games have devised ingenious solutions such as clearing CMOSes with a touch of button at the I/O panel, LED voltage indications, watercooling extensible cooling northbridge, etc. At the same time, we should not forget the SupremeFX Sound attachment... You indeed are paying for a work of art.

I am definitely not inclined to place the Gigabyte board below that of the Maximus, with it's impressive slew of features and connectivity options onboard, and I'm very sure that the FAE team at Gigabyte will be tweaking the BIOS for better performance in time to come. As for the Maximus, with an impressive heatpipe-based heatsink for the chipset, some very innovative features for the overclocker, especially the voltage LED indication. The differences in overclockability between the two boards isn't too far apart considering that both boards has its strength, and it seems pretty evident that Gigabyte's triple quad PWM seems really efficient with Quad Cores. At the end of the day, one might have a really hard time choosing between this two boards.

[ Διαβάστε περισσότερα εδώ...]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Παντα θα χρειαζετε καποιο mod!!!Οσο οι εταιρειες βγαζουν motherboard με σκοπο να πλουτισουνε,καπου θα εχουν κανει λαθος που θα θελει διωρθωση!!!:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now